• About
    • Attorneys
    • Affiliations
    • Press
    • Testimonials
  • Practice Areas
  • Family Law
    • Child Support
    • Child Custody Attorney
      • Child Custody Litigation Cases – Multiple States
    • Dissolution
    • Divorce
    • Domestic Relations Appeals
    • Family Mediation and Arbitration
    • Same Sex Relations Issues – Domestic Partnerships
    • Spousal Support Cases
  • International Family Law
    • International Child Abduction
    • International Divorce
    • The Hague Convention
  • Resource Center
    • Child Custody FAQs
    • Divorce FAQs
  • Gary’s Blog
  • Contact
  • About
    • Attorneys
    • Affiliations
    • Press
    • Testimonials
  • Practice Areas
  • Family Law
    • Child Support
    • Child Custody Attorney
      • Child Custody Litigation Cases – Multiple States
    • Dissolution
    • Divorce
    • Domestic Relations Appeals
    • Family Mediation and Arbitration
    • Same Sex Relations Issues – Domestic Partnerships
    • Spousal Support Cases
  • International Family Law
    • International Child Abduction
    • International Divorce
    • The Hague Convention
  • Resource Center
    • Child Custody FAQs
    • Divorce FAQs
  • Gary’s Blog
  • Contact
In Reversing Sale, Trial Court Overstepped Its Authority
November 19, 2013
Hague Convention and Equitable Tolling: A Matter for the Supreme Court
December 2, 2013

Grandparents’ Rights – Fourth District Opinion Sets a Standard

Published by Gary Gottfried at November 25, 2013
Categories
  • Child Custody
  • Divorce
Tags
  • Appeals
  • Custody
  • Divorce
  • Grandparental Rights
  • Grandparents
  • Ohio Revised Code

The Fourth District Court of Appeals recently issued a very interesting decision regarding the standard that must be met in order for the Court to award companionship rights (visitation) to non-parents, which by definition includes persons such as grandparent and other family members. In the case of McClintock vs. Gould, Case No 12CA23 [PDF], (November 6, 2013) the Fourth District Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s award of visitation rights to the children’s paternal grandmother. In McClintock, the trial court designated the wife as the residential parent and did not award to the father any parenting rights since he was incarcerated and not scheduled for release from prison until 2018.

After the divorce was granted, the paternal grandmother filed a motion to be joined as a party to the divorce case. The Grandmother also filed a motion asking that the Court award to her companionship time with her grandchildren. The mother opposed the motion. The Guardian Ad Litem for the children recommended that the grandmother be granted companionship (visitation) time with the minor children. The trial court granted the motion of the paternal mother and awarded the Grandmother companionship (visitation) time with the grandchildren. The mother appealed the decision. In appealing the decision the mother argued that the grandmother had not filed her motion “timely” because the grandmother had filed her motion after the court had issued the divorce decree. The mother also argued that the Grandmother’s motion should be denied because R.C 3109.051(B) requires that in order for the court to modify a parenting decision that there has to be a change in circumstances regarding the children or the case since the time of the issuance of the divorce decree.

In affirming the trial court’s decision, the Court of Appeals for the Fourth District found that R.C 3109.051(B) is ambiguous because its language is susceptible to more than one reasonable interpretation. The Court of Appeals, in applying the rules of statutory interpretation, concluded that the “change of circumstances requirement” found in R.C 3109.05(B)(1) does not apply to a non-parent if a non-parent files a motion pursuant to R.C 3109.051(B) for visitation or companionship rights for the first time after a court issues a decree or final order in the divorce or other statutorily-enumerated proceedings.

The law on the subject of grandparents’ rights is ever-evolving. For example, R.C. 3109.051 is changing as of January 1, 2014 (see here.) If you are a grandparent who has questions about your rights, or if you are a parent who has concerns about grandparental rights, please do not hesitate to check our FAQs or Contact Us.

Share
0
Gary Gottfried

Related posts

February 29, 2016

How to Split Child’s College Funds during Divorce


Read more
September 15, 2015

International Child Custody Case | Columbus Family Law


Read more
July 17, 2015

Changes to Spanish Law – International Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers


Read more

Comments are closed.

Search The Blog

✕

Blog Categories

  • Bankruptcy
  • Child Abduction
  • Child Abuse
  • Child Custody
  • Child Support
  • Divorce
  • Family Law
  • Hague Convention
  • International Family Law
  • International Matters
  • Legal
  • Prenuptial Agreements
  • Reference
  • Revised Code
  • Same Sex Adoption
  • Same Sex Divorce
  • Uncategorized

Search Our Website

  • About
    • Attorneys
    • Affiliations
    • Press
    • Testimonials
  • Practice Areas
  • Family Law
    • Child Support
    • Child Custody Attorney
      • Child Custody Litigation Cases – Multiple States
    • Dissolution
    • Divorce
    • Domestic Relations Appeals
    • Family Mediation and Arbitration
    • Same Sex Relations Issues – Domestic Partnerships
    • Spousal Support Cases
  • International Family Law
    • International Child Abduction
    • International Divorce
    • The Hague Convention
  • Resource Center
    • Child Custody FAQs
    • Divorce FAQs
  • Gary’s Blog
  • Contact

Reviews

“Gary J. Gottfried knows divorce law better than any other attorney that I do business with. I highly recommend Gary.”

– James Mowery, Esquire

Call Us Now: (614) 297-1211

Location

  • GARY J. GOTTFRIED CO. LPA
  • Family Law Attorneys
  • 608 Office Parkway, Suite B
  • Westerville, OH 43082
  • Phone 1 (614) 297-1211
  • Fax 1 (614) 297-6387

Stay Connected

  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter

Family Law

  • Child Custody
  • Child Support
  • Divorce Law
  • Dissolution
  • Domestic Relation Appeals
  • Family Mediation and Arbitration
  • Same Sex Relations Issues
  • Spousal Support Cases

International Family Law

  • International Divorce Law
  • International Family Law
  • International Child Abduction

Additional Family Law Information

  • Child Custody Litigation Cases – Multiple States
  • Information Needed for Divorce Consultations
  • The Hague Convention
© Gary J. Gottfried Co. LPA | Website Maintained by Archmore Business Web